Taxes. No one really loves them, but we all gotta pay them. Once we become self-employed, we take care of our own taxes, and we do that through quarterly tax payments.
Are you familiar with the time value of money concept? A dollar fifty years ago was worth more than a dollar today. A dollar today is worth more than a dollar ten years from now. Likewise, a dollar today is generally considered to be more valuable than a dollar three months from now.
This is why we always prefer to get our money sooner rather than later. I want to buy my Birkenstocks and Le Creuset pots before they go up in price again. Or, you know, I could invest instead and earn some interest.
Also, people have bills to pay. You wouldn’t sign contracts with 10 clients and say, “You can pay me at the end of the year.” That’s not gonna work. You need the money to cash flow your business. The government is really no different. They want their money now because (a) the time value of money and (b) they have to pay for stuff.
I’m sure, in an ideal world, the IRS would like to levy each of our bank accounts to automatically withdraw our tax payments on a daily basis. That’s not practical. Instead, we pay taxes on a quarterly basis.
DO I HAVE TO PAY QUARTERLY TAXES?
Like how none us have to drive the speed limit, we don’t have to pay quarterly taxes, but there's a good chance you may be penalized for not paying them. Here’s the actual rule:
If you expect to owe at least $1,000 in tax for the taxable year; and you expect your withholding and refundable credits to be less than the smaller of either 90% of the tax to be shown on your return, or 100% of the tax shown on your prior return (when the prior return covered the whole year), you must pay quarterly taxes.
Confused? Me too. I always have to read this rule a few times. Here’s an example to break it down.
Example
Greg, in his second year of business, makes $25,000 from his part-time garage business. He also gets a salary for his full-time job. He owes tax of $10,000 on his total income. Greg has $7,000 withheld from his paycheck for his full-time job. In his first year of business, he owed $8,000. Apply the first part of the rule. Does Greg owe at least $1,000 in tax? Yes. He owes $10,000.
Now apply the second rule, which has two parts. Part one: What would 90% of the tax due be? Here, Greg’s tax due is $10,000. 90% of that would be $9,000. Part two: What was the total tax due for the prior year? Here, Greg’s tax due in the prior year was $8,000. The lessor of those two parts is $8,000. Now, ask whether the amount withheld was less than $8,000. Greg had $7,000 withheld, which is less than $8,000. He must make quarterly tax payments. If Greg had $8,000 withheld, he would not be required to pay quarterly tax (but it would still be advisable for him to set aside the appropriate percentage of his income to eventually pay the tax).
PENALTIES
The IRS has a few different tax penalties that range in amount. The two primary penalties are the late payment penalty and the late filing penalty. A tax return is late and is subject to the late filing penalty if a taxpayer fails to meet the April 15th annual deadline or fails to meet the October 15th deadline if and when they file an extension.
You may initially think the late-payment penalty serves to charge penalties when you fail to pay taxes before those same dates, but that’s only partially true. If you’re required to pay quarterly taxes, then the penalties start to accrue after the deadline if you fail to pay.
By now you know I love a good example, so let’s look at one to see how the late payment penalty works in practice.
EXAMPLE
Let’s assume for simplicity that Barb has taxable income of $100,000 and an effective tax rate of 20%. How much does Barb owe in taxes, and how much should she pay on a quarterly basis?
Do some quick math before moving forward.
ANSWER
Our tax calculation is pretty straightforward. Barb owes tax of 20% of her $100,000 in taxable income, which is $20,000. The IRS wants us to divide that and pay $5,000 in four equal installments, quarterly.
Now, let’s calculate Barb’s penalty assuming that she never made any quarterly tax payments. We will also assume that Barb filed her taxes on April 15th for the previous tax year and paid the full tax on the same date. The quarterly tax due dates are April 15th, June 15th, September 15th, and January 15th. Each payment is for the prior quarter.
When we break this down, we can see that Barb paid her first quarter taxes exactly one year late. Remember they were due on April 15th the year before. Her second payment was 10 months late. The third payment was seven months late, and the final payment was three months late.
We will disregard compound interest for simplicity. Let’s look at the first quarter payment. The penalty is 0.05% per month. 0.05% of $5,000 is $25. That payment was twelve months late, so we multiply $25 by 12 months, which is $300. We do the same calculation for the other three payments, but we multiply that $25 by 10 months, seven months, and three months. Once all the math is done, the total penalty is $800.
Please note that we’re doing a simplified calculation with the goal of achieving a conceptual understanding of quarterly taxes.
Let’s do a bit more analysis. Barb’s tax was $20,000. Her penalty was $800, which is about 4% of the tax due. Generally, whenever I break down the math, the failure to pay quarterly taxes equals between 3 and 5 percent of the total tax due. You can use that as a good rule of thumb/shortcut if you ever want to break down your friend’s tax penalties as a party trick, as one does when seeking cool points.
SHould I go into personal debt to pay quarterly taxes?
As we can see from the example, the penalty for failure to pay quarterly taxes isn’t astronomical. It’s far less than almost all forms of consumer debt. This is why I always share that it’s never worth going into personal debt in order to pay your quarterly taxes.
If it comes down to paying quarterlies and putting your bills on a credit card, or paying those bills, you’d probably want to do the latter if you’re not confident you can quickly pay down that debt.
Time to put this in context. Mary is a wedding planner. She has peaks and valleys in income, which is totally normal in the wedding biz, but when the COVID-19 lockdown hit in spring 2020, it put a major damper on her business and personal finances. Inquiries and bookings dried up, some clients refused to pay, and one client demanded a refund because her wedding was canceled.
Due to COVID-19, the IRS pushed the deadline for quarter two taxes to July 15th. However, Mary was still worried she wouldn’t be able to make the payment. The income she was still receiving was mostly going toward business bills, and she was dipping into her small savings to pay for personal bills doing her best not to put any payments on credit.
Luckily, Mary is one of my students, so she learned all of these concepts. She decided to implement a plan to pause her quarterly tax savings, committed to cut some expenses, and made a plan to start setting aside 30% of all client payments rather than her typical 17%. By doing so, she knew that she’d be caught up on tax payments within a few months. She’d also end up paying about $100 in late-payment penalties. Mary made this decision because that $100 was less than the credit card interest she would rack up, and it was also worth the peace of mind to keep her bank account in the black.
I encourage you not to play games with your quarterlies unless absolutely necessary because it’s a slippery slope, unless you’re a super savvy financial wiz like my friend.
One of my friends used to argue with me about quarterly taxes regularly. He thought they were dumb and pointless. You see, this friend was an avid investor. He bought and sold stocks, cryptocurrency, you name it. He also has an S corp and does quite well in his business. His argument was that he could earn twice as much on his investments than what the IRS would charge him in late payment penalties.
He’d argue, “Why pay the IRS $10,000 now, when I can invest it, make $1,000, pay the tax later, plus the penalty, and still have some left over?” My answer: You can, but that’s a risky game. Also, you then have to pay short-term capital gains tax on the investment, so you may not end up with a net positive.
Long story short, if you’re an investment wiz, you should also be tax savvy enough to crunch the numbers and make a calculated decision. If that’s not you, pay your damn taxes.
Here’s my main takeaway for you: Even if you won't be penalized, or if the penalty is low, it's always a good idea to pay your quarterlies. My advice is this: You need to save for your tax bill even if you don’t have to pay it in installments on a quarterly basis. If you have to save it, you might as well pay it. Also, no one wants to file taxes and get a $12,000 tax bill.
When it becomes a slippery slope
You may be convinced about the importance of quarterly taxes, but if not, let me give you a hypothetical. This isn’t really one person’s story. Rather, it’s an amalgamation of dozens of business owners I have worked with. Let’s call our fictional taxpayer Katya.
Katya starts her business as a life coach. For the first year of her business, Katya isn’t even aware that quarterly taxes are a thing. She never thought about saving for taxes. In year one, Katya earns $22,000. She’s pumped. Her goal was really just to get a couple of clients to start building up her testimonials.
She took Marie Forleo’s B-School course, grabbed a couple of social media programs from Jenna Kutcher, built a website on Squarespace, and had a few other monthly expenses. In total, she spent about $6,000 on her business, leaving her net business income of $16,000. After her standard deduction and qualified business income deduction, her taxable income was only $600.
Katya only ends up owing $150. Bills are still tight for Katya, but right around the time she filed her taxes, she lands another new client. She thinks, Awesome. I’ll just use part of the client’s retainer toward the tax. No problem.
At this point, Katya’s friend gives her the lowdown on quarterly taxes. Katya is well-intentioned, but she has bills to pay, wants to make a couple more investments in her business, and tells herself she’ll start saving in a few months. She doesn’t.
The following tax year rolls around. Over the year, her income doubles. After expenses and deductions, her taxable income is now $30,000. She’s disappointed she never got around to saving, but keeps telling herself, “It won’t be too bad. Last year, I only paid $150.” But now, tax on $30,000 of taxable income comes out to $8,000. That’s an “oh shit” moment. She panics.
After thinking about it for a week, she decides she’ll market really hard that month. Since she’s let her expenses proportionately increase along with her income, she’s still not making a ton of profit. With the promotion and a month of hustle, she scraps together $4,000 for taxes. She creates an installment agreement to pay down the other $4,000 over the next twelve months.
The problem is that now she’s making monthly payments toward the back taxes without saving for next year’s taxes. She makes even more that year, files taxes for year three, and piles that tax debt onto her balance—and the cycle continues. This is the slippery slope with taxes I see every day.
Business owners tell themselves, “I’ll take care of that when I’m making more.” But every time we get more money, we get normalized to it. We increase our spending and nothing really changes. This cycle is a big part of why I created the Unf*ck Your Biz Framework.
If you’re reading this, you’re likely in one of three positions right now. You’re a new business owner who hasn’t started earning any income, and, therefore, don’t owe any back tax. In this case, you’re well ahead of the curve. Read this book and implement the steps.
As an established entrepreneur, you either do or do not have back taxes. If you do have back taxes, I have a blog post for that, You can implement my tips there to get caught up. If you don’t have back taxes, keep doing what you’re doing or make some improvements on your system using the tips in this book.