What is SElf-Employment tax?

In addition to federal income tax, self-employed individuals must also pay self-employment tax on their self-employment income. Luckily, we tackled “What is self-employment income?” in this blog on net business income. Now, we gotta calculate the self-employment tax on the self-employment income.


When you have an employer, the employer withholds taxes from your paycheck. If you check out a pay stub, you'll notice tax withholdings for federal income tax, state income tax, social security, and Medicare.

Collectively, social security and Medicare are called FICA (short for Federal Insurance Contribution Act). FICA totals 15.3% in taxes (up to certain thresholds). When employed, the employer pays half (7.65%) on your behalf. The other half is withheld from your paycheck.

Self-employed people not only must save and pay our income taxes and our share of FICA taxes, but also cover the employer portion. We are, in effect, our own employer. Thus, we have income taxes plus 15.3% self-employment tax on our net self-employment income.

Out of that 15.3% self-employment tax, 2.9% goes toward Medicare. The remaining 12.4% is your contribution to social security. (Side tangent: A politician recently said that contractors shouldn’t get certain benefits because they don’t pay into state coffers. “Ummm, the f*ck” was my first reaction. If you’re properly reporting your income, you’re paying your fair share like everyone else.)

After a certain income level ($137,700 for 2020), you only pay into Medicare and no longer social security. 

Assume you had taxable income of $147,700 in 2020 all from self-employment. The first $137,700 is subject to 15.3% for both medicare and social security. The next $10,000 is only subject to 2.9% medicare tax.



STory Time ON self-employment tax

I discovered my interest in tax law my last year of law school while in federal income tax. Mid-way through, I decided I’d get my LLM in taxation. (An LLM is a master’s degree for attorneys in a specific topic.) I figured I’d need to do well in my tax class to get into the LLM program. I’m happy to report that I got the A*, which is law school speak for the highest grade in the class [insert hair toss].

At the same time, I was on our school’s traveling negotiation competition team. We competed in national competitions. My partner and I got first in one comp and second in another [insert second hair toss]. Also shoutout to my negotiation partner, Amy! I remember when one of our mutual friends asked about a salary proposal she’d gotten from a law firm. This friend came to talk to us since we were the “negotiation people.”

She told us the firm offered her another $10,000—$100,000 total—for her to work for them as a 1099 contractor. That was record-scratch moment. Excuse me, what? First of all, that was arguably not in compliance with California state employment law at the time, but also attorneys have a lot of carve outs, so maybe it was totally fine. Second, I explained to my friend that if she was being paid as a contractor, she’d also be responsible for about an additional $7,000 in self-employment taxes by not being paid as an employee. She’d also be missing out on other benefits. She took this info, went back to her prospective employer, and requested—and received—an additional $10,000 in salary. You never know when some basic tax knowledge will put some extra cash in your pocket.


Calculating self-employment tax

Self-Employment Tax Sample calculation problems

Example 1

Aliyah is an online business manager (OBM). At the end of the year, she does her bookkeeping and finds the gross income of her OBM business was $65,000. She had $15,000 in expenses.

Pause, and do the math on what Aliyah’s self-employment tax would be.

Answer 1

Business income is $65,000 less $15,000, making net business income (NBI) $50,000. Calculate 15.3% self-employment tax by multiplying NBI by 0.153. The total is $7,650.


Example 2

Assume Aliyah’s income and expenses both triple. Calculate self-employment tax.


Answer 2

If the amounts were tripled, business income would be $195,000 and expenses would be $45,000. NBI is $150,000. From there, self-employment tax is calculated in two parts. All income up to $137,700 is taxed at 15.3%.

0.153 x 137700 = $21,068


Income over that threshold is only taxed at 2.9%. First, find the income over $137,000 by subtracting that number from $150,000.

150,000 – 137,700 = 12,300 


Then multiply the $12,300 by 2.9%.

12,300 x 0.029 = $357


Finally, add the two tax totals to find the total tax.

$357 + $21,068 = $21,425

HOw The Qualified business income (QBI) deducation comes into play here

QBI decreases taxes for self-employed folks. Yay! And if you save for taxes just based on what we have calculated so far, you’ll basically have a little bit of a safety cushion.

A little back story. In December 2017, a Republican-controlled Congress, with the support of President Trump, pushed through sweeping new tax legislation. It did many things. We referenced some of those previously. One major change was a slashing of the corporate tax rate.

Many small business owners were pissed. They wanted some benefits too. For a hot minute, we thought the law would kill the benefits of S corps because new businesses might jump straight to C corps. Relatively late in the game, Congress added the sections on QBI to address this issue and threw a bone to us micro businesses since the corporate fat cats were getting such a sweet deal. 

In short, QBI allows business owners to deduct 20% of their "qualified business income" on their tax return. Your income must be under certain thresholds to qualify ($163,300 for single filers and $326,600 for joint filers in 2020).

QBI also only applies to pass-throughs, which I define in more detail in a couple of chapters. So what is qualified business income? The answer is actually pretty nuanced, but for our purposes, we will simplify and say it's basically net business income.

More self-employment tax Calculations

Self-Employment TAx, Now WITH QBI INCLUDED

Example 1

Karen is an artist. She brought in $28,000 in her business and had $8,000 in tax deductible expenses. She also had part-time employment income of $10,000. She takes the standard deduction for single tax filers and has no adjustments. What is Karen’s taxable income? Do the calculation with QBI now in mind.

Answer 2

Karen’s net business income is $20,000, the difference between biz income and expenses. Next calculate a 20% deduction on the net. 20% of $20,000 is $4,000. Deduct that from the $20,000, and now self-employment income is $16,000. Add her other income of $10,000 to that to bump her taxable income back up to $26,000. Finally, subtract the standard deduction of $12,200 to leave taxable income at $13,800.

Get ACCESS TO FREE LEGAL AND TAX RESOURCES

 

RECENT BLOGS

Previous
Previous

HOW TO CALCULATE QUARTERLY TAXES?

Next
Next

Small Business Legal Protection Checklist